Heresies of the Qadianis- Marriage with Hindus
It is quite common knowledge that Quadiani cult does not allow marriage with the Muslims. Some argue that this instruction was given by Mirza; some attribute this to the second Ka-Lip. For the purpose of this article we are not concerned who is responsible for this rule in this cult. But the fact of the matter is that this practice is adopted by the cult.
Recently there had been chatter that Ka-Lip V has sanctioned marriage by Quadianis to the Non-Muslims. We are not a fan of the Ka-Lip V but it is our considered opinion that he is nothing extraordinary or radical compare to elders of his cult. He is following on the foot steps of his cult founders; fortunately they are going astray from the teachings of the Quran, which suits us Muslims perfectly well. But then it is nothing new to this heretical cult. They are masters of distortions, deceptions and lies.
In this article our aim is to expose this practice of Quadiani cult and demonstrate that they act against the Quranic decrees on Muslim’s marriage with non-believers. They claimed to be true Muslims, they also claim to be adherent to the teachings of the Quran.
Marriage with Muslims
Our main aim in this article is not to discuss the marriages of Quadianis with the Muslims but to expose heresy of the cult against the Quran. We need first to demonstrate this cult’s attitude for marriage with the Muslims.
Al-Hukam states in its Dec 1920 publication;
Ahmedis can marry non-Ahmedi girl(s) because it is permissible to marry women belonging to the people of the book(s); it may result in her enlightenment. But our girls should not be given to non-Ahmedis, but we can take their girls.
Ka-LipII writes in his book “Malaika-tullah”
The fifth tenet (of Quadianis) is binding on my sect that you should not give your daughters to the non-Ahmedis. Anyone gives his daughter to a non-Ahmedi does not understand Ahmadiat. Do you find non-Ahmedis giving their daughters to the Hindus or Christians? Non-Ahmedis according to our faith are Kafirs, but they are better then us in this respect. In spite of being Kaffirs themselves, they do not give their daughters to Kaffirs but you despite being Ahmedis give your daughters to non-believers.
It is quite obvious that this Cult considers Muslims as Kaffirs and does not allow marriage with the Muslims. We consider it to be blessing in disguise. But as stated earlier, this is not the main purpose of this article; we may visit this avenue in the future.
The critics and even the Lahoris blame Ka-lip II for introductions of these ideas in to Quadianiat. We disagree strongly; we have absolutely no doubt that the heresies of Ka-Lip II are based on the lies and deceptions of Mirza.
Mirza verdict on deniers of Quran
Mirza in Ruhani Khazain V22 writes;
Mirza in response to a Question responded;
Q: Hazoor written in thousands of places, calling the recites of the Kalima and those who pray towards the Qibla as Kaffirs is not correct practice. It is apparent that by not accepting you no one can become Kaffir except those who denounce you as Kaffir. But you have written to Abdul Hakim Khan that any one who receives my claims but does not accept me is not Muslim. There is contradiction in this statement and statements in earlier books. In Taryaq-e-Qulub you wrote no one become Kaffir by not accepting me. But now you write that one becomes Kaffir by denying me.
A: It is strange that you consider the one who calls me Kaffir and the one who does not accept my claims two different people. Even though for Khuda there are of the same kind. Because anyone who does not accept me; does not accept me because he considers me as a liar. But Allah Talla (SWT) decreed that anyone who lies against the Word of Khuda (SWT) is worse then Kaffirs. It is decreed in Quran (quoted from Surah A’raf V37) that there are two grand Kafirs; one which associate lies to Allah SWT, second one which insults Word of Khuda (SWT). In this situation I am not only Kafir but a Grand Kaffir. But if I am not a liar then this Kuffar would be on my accuser.
Mirza in the foot note clarified his answer further, he writes;
Cruel here means Kaffir, the one who make fun of Word of Allah (Quran) compare to a liar is called cruel. With out any doubt the one who make fun of Word of Allah (Quran) is a Kaffir. Therefore; one who does not recognize me and declare me a Kaffir by considering me a liar, he is a Kaffir by denying me.
We can safely conclude that according to Mirza the one who make fun of the Word of Allah SWT is the Biggest Kaffir. We will also examine Mirza’s logic that anyone who consider him a liar and thus declare him a Kaffir is performing Kufar.
This proves that it was Mirza who has declared Muslims as Kaffir; Ka-lip II was only reiterating the point to his followers and he indeed did not coined these phrases for the Muslims.
Quranic evidence for the deniers of Word of Allah SWT
7:37 (Asad) And who could be more wicked than they who attribute their own lying inventions to God or give the lie to His messages? Whatever has been decreed to be their lot [in life] will be theirs -till there shall come _ unto them Our messengers to cause them to die, [and] shall say, "Where, now, are those beings whom you were wont to invoke beside God?" And [those sinners] will reply, "They have forsaken us!" -and [thus] they will bear witness against themselves that they had been denying the truth.
We intend to show to our readers that this Ka-lip II was a denier of Word of Allah SWT and he is guilty of the heresies which his father falsely accuse the Muslims. There is no better way then to expose a liar in his own words and by evidence from the sources of this cult. We will also prove that Mahmud indeed was a Muftri and Muslims rightly reject this cult as bunch of heretic and deniers of the Word of Allah SWT, the Holy Quran. We have the words of Mirza stated above and we intend to prove that according to his father’s logic and teachings Mahmud was a Kaffir indeed.
Marriage to Hindus allowed in Islam?
Mahmud writes; According to Islam marriage is allowed with a Hindu and Jewish girl. Even though it is not a practice at the moment. If a Muslim man marry Hindu or Jewish girl then the Muslims would pronounce him Kaffir. But in Islam such marriage is allowed. These marriages widen the relationships. It would be so nice that a Muslim loves his Grandson (from a son) as Muslim and another Hindu Grandson (from daughter) calls him with love and affection. By adopting this approach religious differences would be eliminated. Difference of color and language would be eliminated. Allah Tallah (SWT) spread the rain water to the whole earth not just a specific place. The rain even falls on canals, rivers, and on oceans, on uncultivated and cultivated land, on the Gardens and on dirty waste streams.
Before we proceed to examine the writings of Mahmud, we like to point out an absurdity of Mahmud; Qamar-ul-Anbiya “Moon of the Prophets”. Even though Mehmood started the pessage by stating that if a Muslim man marries a Hindu or Jewish girl, but in the middle of the passage, when he described grandsons, he reversed it, he called Hindu (Nawasa) Grandson, which indicate grandson from the daughter and not from the son, in Urdu language. This grandson could only result if a woman gets married with a Hindu man, not a Muslim man marrying a Hindu girl.
In essence Mehmood is claiming that the marriage of Muslims girls with Hindu men is also allowed in Islam.
Quranic evidence against Mehmud
2:221 AND DO NOT marry women who ascribe divinity to aught beside God ere they attain to [true] belief: for any believing bondwoman [of God] is certainly better than a woman who ascribes divinity to aught beside God, even though she please you greatly. And do not give your women in marriage to men who ascribe divinity to aught beside God ere they attain to [true] belief: for- any believing bondman [of God] is certainly better than a man who ascribes divinity to aught beside God, even though he pleases you greatly. [Such as] these invite unto the fire, whereas God invites unto paradise, and unto [the achievement of] forgiveness by His leave; and He makes clear His messages unto mankind, so that they might bear them in mind.
It is quite clear from Quranic evidence that marriage to “Mushrik” women is not permissible for Muslim men.
Not only that Quran forbid the marriage with Mushriks, but clarify that those who ascribe divinity to anyone except Allah SWT are Mushriks. This Verse also forbids giving Muslim women in marriage to Mushrik men. Therefore, Quranic decree is against both lies of Mehmood in above quoted paragraph from his writings.
Allah SWT ordered that Muslims should investigate before Marriage to the women who have converted to Islam.
60:10 O YOU who have attained to faith! Whenever believing women come unto you, forsaking the domain of evil, examine them, [although only] God is fully aware of their faith; and if you have thus ascertained that they are believers, do not send them back to the deniers of the truth, [since] they are [no longer] lawful to their erstwhile husbands, and these are [no longer] lawful to them. None the less, you shall return to them whatever they have spent [on their wives by way of dower]; and [then, O believers,] you will be committing no sin if you marry them after giving them their dowers. On the other hand, hold not to the marriage-tie with women who [continue to] deny the truth, and ask but for [the return of] whatever you have spent [by way of dower] -just as they [whose wives have gone over to you] have the right to demand.
Quranic decree makes it obligatory on Muslim men that if believing women come unto them for the purpose of the Marriage; if these women belonged to some group of non-believers or Musrhiks in other words. They should investigate their claims that they have attained to faith. Even though what is in their hearts only known to Allah SWT but He SWT still make obligatory for the Muslims to do investigation and satisfy themselves of their status as believers. If they do duty they are assigned by Allah SWT in this Quranic decree then no blame is attached to them. Allah SWT knows what is in the hearts of the hypocrites if they do not believe on what they pronounce.
This Verse also decreed that once these women attained to the faith and become Muslims they are not lawful to their previous partners who are non-believers or Mushriks. Therefore, clear cut decree by Allah SWT those Muslim women can not marry or remain in marriage to men who are not believers or are Mushriks.
We Muslims know very well that Hindus worship different deities, and Shirk and Kuffar according to Quranic definitions is prevalent practice among them.
Quranic decree is very unambiguous; we Muslims are not allowed to marry anyone who does not believe in the Unity of Allah SWT and/or worship any idol.
Hypocrisy by the Cult
Funnily enough this cult is full of hypocrites we have exposed hypocrisy of Ka-LipII that he accuses Muslims but he conveniently forgot the writings of his father and founder of this cult.
But their hypocrisy is not limited to the Ka-Lip II. We find these gems on their official web site. In the web edition of the book Pathway to Paradise; the writer stated;
Islam also makes clear whom a Muslim is allowed to marry as far as his/her religion is concerned. Marriage with an idolater is totally forbidden (see Holy Qur'an, 2:222) for both sexes. However, men are allowed to marry women of the "people of the Book" (i.e., those who follow a revealed scripture), although it is not considered preferable.
We humbly request such writers that they should research teachings of their founders before writings such passages. Do these ignorant people realise that they are destroying the credibility of their own cult?
We can only thank the writer to prove Mehmud as Kazzab and a Kaffir by acting against the decree of the Quran the Word of Allah SWT.
We have demonstrated that Mehmud was a liar and a heretic to claim that Islam allows marriage to the Hindus.
We have also proven conclusively that Mehmud was a Muftri according to the conditions and tests set out by his father in the quoted passage from his book It also proves conclusively that Mehmud was a non-believer and a Kaffir who did not believe in the Word of Allah SWT; he did not followed the decrees in the Quran and declared marriage with Hindus permissible against the Word of Allah SWT.
All we can say is that good luck to Masroor; he is doing nothing extraordinary but following the teachings of this cult’s founders. We are glad that these heretics do not allow marriages with the Muslims. After all those who allow marriages to the non-believers disobeying Allah SWT, what they have to do with Islam and Muslims?
All rights reserved © 2009